Sunday, December 3, 2006

Pleasure

Ron's got me thinking again. She's right about the strangeness that often befalls the comments over at Twisty's place. I find Twisty's commentary to be interesting, and thought-provoking, and I often agree with a substantial percentage of what she says. Our tastes on some things may differ, and we could have an interesting discussion about how much taste is constructed by patriarchy (and, i would say, capitalism--I regard them as complementary but not identical by any means)--if patriarchal capitalism is really totalizing, then, I might argue, we shouldn't differ even as much as we do. We should be lined up for whatever product(s) and belief(s) we're fed. I'd argue that humans are messier than that, our desires are less easily codified, and neither patriarchy nor capitalism has managed to control all of either the horizontal or the vertical. Although I'm also not about to break into song celebrating the Unquenchable Human Spirit or anything (and, trust me, you do not want me to break into song about anything; a quiet hum, perhaps, that no one else can hear, but that's about it).

But what I really wanted to discuss was blojobs (yes, I'm misspelling it intentionally). Twisty commented some time ago--August, I think--that BJs were . . . not to her taste. She might have been more vehement than that (she might have called them disgusting, for example), but I do not remember her description and I'm too lazy to go find the post. Teh Internets blowed up. There were hundreds of comments, many of which detailed the commenter's preferences and practices (which, trust me, was often way too much information). Many women wrote in, in defense of the lowly (and, apparently, about to be outlawed AND discredited) BJ. (Personally, I didn't realize they were so endangered as to require such defense, but what do I know.) This, in turn, invited others to point out that these defenses of BJs were yet another aspect of the patriarchy that the defenders had, uh, swallowed, i.e., that women who claim to like giving BJs suffer from false consciousness (because no woman could possibly like giving them), or that women who claim to like giving them merely say that for the same reasons that women claim to like wearing spike heels and ripping their pubic hair out by the roots and so on, i.e., the patriarchy has trained them successfully.

I felt like I'd stumbled down a rabbit hole, if you want to know.

I finally figured out (I think) that many young (by which I mean "10+ years younger than I am") women have, indeed, swallowed the patriarchy-and-pron(again intentional)-influenced prescriptions regarding applying their mouths to male genitalia. Apparently (so far as I can tell), BJs are featured prominently in pron, and given the much wider availability of such visual fare these days, many young men want what they see, and many young women feel that they should provide it, no matter what their own preferences happen to be. That is, many men want sexbots, and many women believe they should be sexbots. (Yes, I know, YOU don't feel that way; me neither. It's only benighted Others who ever feel any pressure to be attractive.) Thus, an activity that, for some of us, might well arise as part of the generally pleasurable touching and such, has been reappropriated by the patriarchy in such a way that, for a whole lot of young men and women, it has a whole other set of meanings involving dominance and so on.

It was always thus, of course--that's how a patriarchy works; the only thing that changes is the definition of sexbot and the comparative ability of women to resist or defy sexbotification. Until the 1970s, for example, women could not get credit cards in their own names. Many single women had trouble getting mortgages. While women continue to be underpaid for the work they do, it was way worse back then, when it was difficult for a woman to support herself alone. You can't be independent if you can't buy your own food. On the other hand, after a brief period of feminist free-for-all and free love (back to that in a second, too), patriarchy reasserted itself. That's why so many women engage in feminism-bashing, and why so many women adopt the gear of the patriarchy and defend it as their "taste" or their "preference." Like Twisty, I'm somewhat loathe to blame women for what is essentially a survival strategy, but it also saddens me to watch young women twist themselves into knots and strap themselves into sports corsets all while insisting what they're doing is (to borrow a Twistyism) empowerful.

And sometimes I think I've had a glimpse of a better way.

For a brief period of time, there was a moment of freedom: between the old patriarchal "Leave it to Beaver" vacuuming in pearls standard and the new patriarchal "pearl necklace" standard, before herpes and HIV (but, alas, not before HPV) and after contraception became legal and available. Yes, dearies, contraception was illegal in many places, until 1965, when the Supreme Court said, in Griswold v. Connecticut, that there was a right to privacy that covered such things--this is controversial because that right (a) is not specifically mentioned in the Constitution, as such, and (b) is part of the eventual justification for Roe v. Wade. It's also why, if you read the writings of the people who want to control your uterus, you've started seeing mention of Griswold. The godbag wingnuts want to eliminate access to contraception completely, which is tucked in among the reasons why they attack Planned Parenthood so vehemently. They're not just opposed to abortion, they're also opposed to contraception, and, essentially, to women having any control over their own bodies.

But I digress.

Part of "women's lib" (and, yes, I'm old enough to have been asked if I was a "women's libber") was sexual liberation--"Our Bodies, Ourselves" came out of that impulse, I'd argue, insofar as it was a move for women to reclaim their bodies from the medical (and mostly male) establishment. Sexual pleasure was a part of that, and it was about sexual pleasure for its own sake, and sexual pleasure that wasn't about pleasing men. Was it always successful? Of course not. But there are a bunch of us--women AND men, I'd say--who discovered, for the umpteenth time, that rubbing up against each other can provide all kinds of great fun (and that one didn't have to be In Love to do that, but that's a different part of the argument, into which i won't go today, even though it's not unrelated). The whole BJ dustup was puzzling to me, until I began to suspect that for many younger women, the patriarchy has (not surprisingly) coopted women's rediscovery of sexual pleasure and once again turned it into a tool for pleasing men. Somehow, I mostly missed that boat, however.

And I think the patriarchal structure (insofar as a structure can be said to have wants or desires) wants to squash the impulse toward uninhibited sexual pleasure. Not just to oppress women for the hell of it, and not just because women can have multiple orgasms, but because sexual pleasure, especially of the ecstatic kind, is wild and a little uncontrollable and powerful--for men AND women. And we wouldn't want people, especially female people, feeling powerful, now, would we--much better that they wear a sports corset and feel empowerful instead. Much better that women's sexual experience serve the patriarchy. And much better that men be worried about maintaining their dominance than giving themselves up to ecstasy (and, trust me, the patriarchy doesn't want individual men to be powerful in any way that does not serve the patriarchy).

But sometimes I like to think that there's this little group of renegades out here, men and women both, who have taken a walk on that ecstatic side (and I'm not saying that that's not possible within a Relationship, though I would say that some aspects of marriage, etc., definitely serve the patriarchy). Neither the men nor the women want to be told that that pleasure is bad or wrong--we know otherwise. I'd also add that we know that that pleasure isn't about power, or about dominance--it's contrary to those things, IMHO. Is it possible to experience sex outside the confines of the dominance that defines the patriarchy? Yeah, sometimes, for a little while, anyway--as long as the scripts didn't come from patriarchally produced pron, but instead came from more primal or immediate experience of touching.

And that might be where I begin to diverge from Twisty, just a little. Yes, I know we experience everything within the confines of some structure or another--there's no language outside language, either--which means we experience that touching within a structure, too. But when the earth moves, all bets are off, at least for a flash of time.

7 comments:

kStyle said...

I like what you say.

Twisty is too polarizing for me. I occasionally read, but never comment.

A thought: isn't blaming everything on the Patriarchy, in a way, giving the Patriarchy too much power? I'm not a Patriarchy-denier, per se, but I think there's more too it.

Narya said...

I find that not reading the comments, or only reading the commenters I think are sensible, helps. Twisty likes to mix it up, and I think the way she challenges her readers helps me be clearer about what I think. But the commenters often go all over the place, and often not in directions that illuminate much of anything.

Anonymous said...

Yes! Yes about that window, and yes about pleasure. It's the oddest thing to realize that the idea that pleasure is good and doesn't have to be "earned" is evidently news again. Still. Yet.

No it doesn't have to be earned. It only has to be agreed to.

The other thing that got my attention in that melee (I read as much as I could stand of it on several blogs; guess I was in a roadkill mood) was that evidently, to at least many of the commenters and maybe by most of their demographic(s), "bohjab" means "deet phroating" and not any of the more playful random or@l stuff one might get around to. Hello, if you're g@gging, why bother? It's all supposed to feel good! For you! Right then! Without thinking about it! You don't have to put up with anything!

Phew.

You know, I'm going to think some more too, see if I can articulate what's been my underlying attitude since those thrilling days of yesteryear.

Narya said...

I'd love to read what you have to say, Ron--you were one of the few sensible commenters (IMHO).

I think you're absolutely right about the "Right then!" part, and I think there's something important in there. It's probably why I've always regarded some of the more esoteric clothing arrangements as peculiar--it seems more about theater than anything else. which is fine, if you're a thespian.

Anonymous said...

Yeah, and if you're a thespian you get to take the weird clothes off after the show, and go home in your sweats if you want.

Orange said...

This is a mighty thoughtful post. (Is the the promised thoughtfullyness?)

I never took a women's studies class, and I've missed out on learning any rad-fem theory. So I occasionally use Twisty's blog as a primer for a novice blamer (I know she forbids that)—no, I'm not gonna wade into the discussions there. But the posts have raised my consciousness, as it were, which is good.

Anonymous said...

I never took a women's studies class either, Orange, because they hadn't been invented when I was in school. When I was in academic school, that it, as opposed to the "trade" schools later. Sometimes I look over my shoulder, though, wondering if I'm being studied.

I rather think that what Twisty forbids is the kind of clueless comment she sometimes gets from novice feminists -- or, more often, deliberately obtuse fingers-in-the-ears types. It wouldn't be reasonable to forbid someone from reading IBTP, after all. I think it's as good a place to start as any.