I love the Oxford comma. My next husband will be the Oxford comma. Seriously, that was the way my 7th & 8th-grade grammar teacher (Hello, Mr. Roth!) taught commas and that's the way I like it. I have been known to give in to the pressure and omit it, though. Guess I'm fickle.
Because--and I know you wrongly believe otherwise--the unmade bed is not a harbinger of the decline of civilization. If I close my bedroom door, no one would even know (but I don't care enough to close the door). Serial commas are out there in the world, though, for everyone to see, or not, and thus have a much greater impact. (If I really wanted to get on my own nerves, I'd use impact as a verb in that sentence, but I just cannot. It is NOT a verb, damnit!)
It's not the unmade bed that foreshadows the decline of civilization. It's the creeping abandonment of self-discipline, and the attitude that it doesn't matter as long as no one sees it.
Regarding commas, give it up. If it were possible to stop the language from evolving, we would all be speaking and writing a language that you wouldn't even recognize. Let the rule be "If it makes sense, do it." Don't fight me on this, or I will have to impact you.
It's true that one could level many criticisms at me, but "lacks self-discipline" isn't likely to be one of them. Thus, if observers want to conclude that my refusal to waste my time rearranging fabric on which I am going to sleep (or whatever) signals a lack of self-discipline on my part, well, they can join you in being wrong.
And, as you can see from the other commenters here, serial commas have friends. Important friends. Editor-type friends. (And what's with all this talk of violence from you lately?)
8 comments:
I love the Oxford comma. My next husband will be the Oxford comma. Seriously, that was the way my 7th & 8th-grade grammar teacher (Hello, Mr. Roth!) taught commas and that's the way I like it. I have been known to give in to the pressure and omit it, though. Guess I'm fickle.
Nothing short of Civilization herself depends on the serial comma.
OK, if this serial comma thing is important to civilization (and I agree that it is), why do you not make your bed?
Because--and I know you wrongly believe otherwise--the unmade bed is not a harbinger of the decline of civilization. If I close my bedroom door, no one would even know (but I don't care enough to close the door). Serial commas are out there in the world, though, for everyone to see, or not, and thus have a much greater impact. (If I really wanted to get on my own nerves, I'd use impact as a verb in that sentence, but I just cannot. It is NOT a verb, damnit!)
It's not the unmade bed that foreshadows the decline of civilization. It's the creeping abandonment of self-discipline, and the attitude that it doesn't matter as long as no one sees it.
Regarding commas, give it up. If it were possible to stop the language from evolving, we would all be speaking and writing a language that you wouldn't even recognize. Let the rule be "If it makes sense, do it." Don't fight me on this, or I will have to impact you.
It's true that one could level many criticisms at me, but "lacks self-discipline" isn't likely to be one of them. Thus, if observers want to conclude that my refusal to waste my time rearranging fabric on which I am going to sleep (or whatever) signals a lack of self-discipline on my part, well, they can join you in being wrong.
And, as you can see from the other commenters here, serial commas have friends. Important friends. Editor-type friends. (And what's with all this talk of violence from you lately?)
About the bed-making: I'm just being contrary, for the heck of it. Don't make yours if you don't want to.
About the commas: It really doesn't matter how important are the friends of the comma. Eventually usage determines the rules. Embrace clarity.
About the violence: Just living up to my patriarchal responsibilities. Do you think it's easy subjugating women? Requires constant vigilance.
Fun pseudo-fact: Not making your bed is healthier than making it.
Post a Comment