Sunday, January 20, 2008

This, That, the Other

Three professors are stranded on a desert island. They have canned food, but no can opener. The physicist says he can figure out how to force the cans open without losing the contents. The chemist says she can identify chemical reactions that will get the cans open without destroying or tainting the contents. The economist says, "Assume a can opener."

When I was in graduate school, the graduate students most likely to annoy the crap out of me were the econ students. In addition to being narrow-minded (in not one but several different ways), they were unhappy, miserable people, and they seemed to think that was a fair price to pay for having our university's name on their diploma. (I knew one guy who was a true exception to these rules, and I wish I could remember his name. He had a long ponytail, and a cheerful demeanor--at one point, he won some small award, and he took the money that came with it and threw a party, which I thought was really quite nice.) The thing that always annoyed me about economists, though, from the time I was an undergraduate, is that their models of the world just didn't seem informative or interesting. The whole ceteris paribus thing seemed like a copout to me, not least because it seemed to take the most important questions and assume them away (or, in some cases, reduce them in such a way as to be overly simplistic). I understand the point of models, which is what economists (and game theorists) use to remove the messy complexities of real life, but it has often seemed to me that the better and more informative path is to explore those complexities. For example, economists and game theorists often describe people's motivations as, for example, self-interested; even people who behave in what we might describe as altruistic ways are getting pleasure of some kind from their behavior and are therefore, in this model, self-interested. Not only do I regard that as eye-rollingly stupid, I don't see how it illuminates any questions we want answered. People act from a variety of motivations, often from several at once, and reducing them all to "self-interest"--and a particularly crabbed version of that--does not shed any useful light on human behavior.

In any case, Paul Krugman is steadily forcing me to revise my disdain for economists. In addition to his twice-weekly column, he has a blog, and I find it extremely educational. (And not just because he titled it after his newest book, "The Conscience of a Liberal.") Rather than doing the kind of game theoretic work that surrounded me in grad school, he looks at various economic data and tries to make some sense of it.

From the feminism front, I've been thinking about the Germaine Greer quote (both Twisty and Echidne have posted it), to the effect that women have no idea how much men hate them. And, indeed, I think there is a great deal of truth in that, in that there are some, perhaps many, men who really do hate women. They may want to have sex with women, and they may make exceptions of various sorts for women in their own personal lives, but, in general, they really do regard women as this awful, Other creature, as beings who are fundamentally different from men (who are normal and the norm). Consider the cartoons about Hil that mithras assembled--all from one cartoonist!--and his analysis of the misogyny at the root of them. Consider the uproar in the blogopshere about Chris Matthews (I don't have a handy link for that one, because I've been doing my best to just ignore it). Consider the men who want to decide what I can do with my uterus, or the men who think that men really should be the deciders in the household.

Yeah, I know, none of you or the men with whom you associate are like that, and, like me, you probably do your best to avoid them, and you likely work in places where they cannot spew their vile hatred without getting canned. (More likely, there are a few closet misogynists around you.) Even the men closest to us are likely to display some sexism once in awhile--we do live in a patriarchal culture, after all, and we absorb tropes and behaviors and memes from it without even realizing it--but not that outright misogyny. Thus, many women AND men have no idea how much some men hate women. What this also means, though, is that men who don't hate women are particularly clueless about the extent of the hatred or the many forms it takes.

On one hand, I don't regard it as my obligation to educate the fucking world about misogyny: if you're truly "well-meaning," or a feminist, or not a hater, or whatever, then it's your obligation to learn what you can about it, without getting all defensive all the damned time and trying to declare "but I'm not like that!!" Let's face it--it's possible to learn about all kinds of injustice without actually experiencing it. I see the whole thing as a social justice issue, and if men are serious about social justice, then they need to recognize misogyny and patriarchy for the evils that they are.

On the other hand, part of the education is, or can be, experiencing it, and men simply do not experience the everyday shit to which women become accustomed. Thus, holding men responsible for experience they cannot acquire isn't useful. (Though men who (a) diminish reports of this experience or (b) turn the conversation to their own tewwible, howwible, experiences, which ARE TOO awful! need to STFU and listen, fer chrissakes, and not just in hopes of getting laid or to prove that they're not women-haters.) WAY too often, even well-meaning men dismiss stories of sexism with their own tales of woe or with supposedly funny dismissals. Let me tell you, guys, it's tiresome. And while you may not be imposing it on anyone, or you may not think you're doing it, that guy in the cubicle next to you? He wouldn't do laundry if his life depended on it. The guy on the other side talks to women's breasts. The woman across the way didn't get as big a promotion or raise, and she came in at a lower salary than the bozo who does less work than she does.

And don't even get me started on the "but men are subject to the patriarchy too!!" Yes, I know they are. And they benefit from it, mightily, even men who are not themselves women-haters. Susie Bright had an interesting post on her blog about Suze Orman, who apparently came out recently. I don't watch Orman, and I had no idea she was lesbian (and I don't care)--she annoys me, as a matter of fact, because the little of her I've seen seems pretty simplisitic--but the article was fascinating (go read the whole thing, but probably not at work).
What Orman is saying, a tiny bit more openly, in her new book, is that she knows most women’s money lives are defined by their dependence on men, be they husbands, lovers, or fathers. She is urging women, rhetorically, to cut it off.

I know the word “virtue” sounds old-fashioned—but so is the urge to “find a man,” and “have a baby” with said man. Those goals are more pressing than ever, as feminist philosophy becomes a novelty item.

In lesbian culture, there’s no currency in being sexually virtuous. No one cares if you have slept with “X” number of women before you sleep with them—not because they’re so open-minded, but because there’s no economic basis. There’s no “finding out whose baby this is.”

Lesbian sexuality is not designed to answer any notion of virtue; it doesn’t answer a patriarch’s need. This is why Suze Orman is incredulous that straight women keep getting taken to the cleaners financially—she is oblivious to the “call of virtue,” no matter how many New Age platitudes she espouses.

Traditionally-brought up women think that if they try, try, try, to take care of everyone and deny themselves fulfillment beyond retail-trivia, that they will get their BIG REWARD. You know, the "push present."

Or, earlier: "Money and sex get confused with virtue, and virtue is a feminine trait. There is a great deal of belief among women that if they are “good”—that is to say, modest and self-deferential in their needs, be they orgasmic or financial—they’ ll be rewarded with the status of respected wife and mother."

My perspective is actually similar to Bright's and Orman's, in that I never expected a man would take care of me or support me financially (except for that very brief moment when Chuck was supposed to return the favor for me taking care of him for years, and we see how THAT turned out). I always assumed I'd be making my own way—even if I had a partner in there at some point. Even now, I get a little appalled at the number of women who apparently didn't learn anything from reading about the 1970s and earlier. All the "push presents" in the world aren't going to pay the fucking rent if he decides he wants someone younger in his bed, or, for that matter, if some tragedy happens.

I'll go further than Bright: straight women aren't supposed to care about money, at least not about earning decent money at a good job. It's unfeminine, and men feel all emasculated and shit if you make more than they do (though, guys, keep in mind that she probably makes less than the men at her level at her workplace, even if she does the same work and/or a better job at it). Much better that women get demanding about jewelry and such, not least because those trinkets are dispensed by and at the pleasure of the man. You don't even have to make more than men for them to get all anxious: many men are unnerved by women who are self-sufficient. If you don't "need" them, then you might leave them, whereas if a woman depends on a man financially, well, it's a lot harder to leave. (Here I'm wishing my friend would stop lurking and tell her story . . . you know who you are!) Yeah, I know, you guys out there are exceptions, YOU don't feel that way, or you women are partners with guys who don't feel that way, but I'm not making up this shit.

But I find self-sufficiency very freeing, and I know more than a few men who feel the way I do about it. A fair number of men seem to be relieved when they find a partner with whom they're not expected to . . . take care of things. Of course, the tradeoff is that they have to clean the bathroom, or do the laundry, or perform whatever other shitwork the situation demands, but, hey, that's life.

(And, yes, I know, shit can happen to make self-sufficiency nearly impossible, and I know that all of us depend on myriad others for all kinds of things; that's not what I mean. That's human interdependency, and it's part of life. What I mean is the assumption, on the part of women and/or men, that they'll end up in a dyad and that in that dyad he's going to make more money--that he will, in some way, "take care of" her, and that she, therefore, does not need, and should not want, to put as much energy into making a living.)

Speaking of patriarchy, enjoy the football games today, or enjoy ignoring them.

4 comments:

landismom said...

Since my daughter has become school-aged, I have been mind-boggled by the number of women I have met who are, as you put it, ignoring the lessons of the 70s. I cannot believe it, when I meet a woman who, when she finally went back to work after her kids are in elementary school, just got a part-time job. Or one who works in a fast food restaurant, because that has a schedule that allows her to be home after school.

I'm happy to say that I'm the primary income-earner in my family. I can't imagine ever being financially dependent on a man, and I'm happy that my partner isn't threatened by that.

Anonymous said...

...men who really do hate women. They may want to have sex with women, and they may make exceptions of various sorts for women in their own personal lives...

Consider that the most hostile phrase in the vernacular is "Fuck you!" and that seeming paradox might resolve itself. They hate the women they have sex with, TOO. Maybe even more.

And the rest of your post: OH yeah.

Anonymous said...

Dittos.

kStyle said...

That's interesting about Suze Orman. I dig her message, even if I find her communications style a little brassy.

I like it when you have more time to post.