Tuesday, December 23, 2008

Reasons Why Top Chef Annoys Me

1. It's bad television.
There actually are several pieces to this, but it can be summed up by noting that the suspense is so fucking manufactured as to make me want to smack somebody. And even this is annoying on several levels, but I don't want to get too carried away with my outline formatting here.

First off, I really fucking hate reality shows--there's the putting-writers-out-of-work thing; there's the manufactured bits pretending they're not manufactured; there's the notion that this is in any way whatsoever "reality"; there's the scripting and editing; there are the premises of many of the shows. Most important, though, there's the completely overwrought drama of the whole thing.

People, it's a show about cooking. Noone is going to cure cancer. Noone is going to invent anything useful. No lives will be saved. Someone will almost certainly Learn Something, because the moral seems to be that One Must Learn From One's Experiences. Which, yes, I get, and even agree with, but I don't think the things one should learn are the lessons I hear parroted on these shows, or at least not on the few that I've seen.

The other part about the drama is that it's just bullshit. Seriously. (I find things like "Survivor," which I've seen once, and the one with the teams trying to get from one place to another, which I've seen once, even more tedious than the ones I've seen more.) Did I mention it's a cooking contest? It's basically a Pillsbury Bake-Off each week, and the contestants have tattoos and creative facial hair rather than aprons and pumps. Think about the good suspense/drama that you've seen--I'm thinking now about something like "Hill Street Blues," or even "M*A*S*H" in the good years, or "Northern Exposure," or any of a zillion different shows. They were suspenseful and dramatic because you came to like and know the characters. I realize that the producers of these shows are creating characters from their contestants, but see above, re: actual writers and the producers versus whoever is "creating" the characters, or, at least, characterizations.

And that kind of points to the real tension here. All of us have suspense and drama in our lives, except it is often messy, and it often doesn't fit neatly, and we don't always learn the right lessons from our experiences (or learn any lessons at all, for that matter), and shit just happens, and most of it is tedious to people who don't know us (and probably to some who do). Some of it seems good; some seems bad; some is just . . . shit. But that kind of actual life doesn't really fit into "reality" shows all that much, though it occasionally breaks through.

Instead there's all this manufactured drama about the undercooked egg, or the raw scallop (yes, Jamie gets on my nerves, plus, can she cook with anything other than scallops?), or the extra mushrooms, all these long serious faces, and tears and hugging, and discussions among the judges in serious tones that make it sound like it's Life Or Death, rather than a cooking contest.

Also, the long-drawn-out pauses? The huge commercial breaks at Crucial Moments? Yeah, I suppose that latter one is understandable, but the former is really fucking annoying. I'd much rather they have more in-depth discussions, discuss the dishes or cooking theory or whatthefuckever in more depth, rather than long pregnant pauses before someone is told to pack his or her knives. It's really a wasted opportunity to put actual, real drama in the show; instead they replace it with the aforementioned pregnant pauses.

Let's hear the judges having a longer discussion; let's have more of the contestants discussing what they tried to do with a given dish, BEFORE the judges' panel, maybe even with some honesty about what they think worked and what they think didn't work; maybe even, if you want to add some drama, have the contestants judge each other's dishes in some way that doesn't get someone thrown under the bus. All of those options would provide real information, and, at least potentially, real drama, instead of the crap. A final note to the producers on this: little segments on this or that person's life history do not turn people into Characters. I'd rather hear about dishes that so-and-so tried and loved; that worked really well in the restaurant but that the staff hated for some reason; that the staff loved but that didn't work, and why not. Quite frankly, that would give me more insight into what the cheftestants are thinking than little tidbits on this one's gay, that one's flirting, the other one's old.

2. There's no joy.
Fuck; there's not even humor! I realize that humor, like drama, comes in part from the characters, and it's difficult to do that on a show like this, but there is no humor at all. There's a lot of sturm und drang; there's tense nail-biting; there's stress and tension and flinging things around the kitchen, but don't these people ever fucking laugh? Stefan and Fabio seem to laugh once in awhile, or at least make jokes, but no one else does. Don't they enjoy what they're doing?

I can't quite figure this one out. I don't know about places like Charlie Trotter's or Everest (the latter of which is a silent kitchen, which means the only thing you say is "Yes, Chef"), because, hey, the bakery was not those places, and the joy there may work differently. But every place I've ever worked has . . . some kind of happiness and laughter around it. Bossman regularly cracked me up, as did Phil, because they're both genuinely funny people.

But there was also joy. I don't know how else to put it. There's something just about taking water, sugar, butter, flour, yeast, and salt, and making beautiful, delicate croissants. Yes, it was grinding and grueling, but even in the middle of that we managed to laugh with each other, and, more to the point, there's a love of at least aspects of the doing. And there's also a joy in the rhythm of it all, of stepping in at just the right moment to help Phil toss the baguette dough through the one-way sheeter (thereby saving him 15 or 20 minutes), then stepping back into whatever I was doing; and a joy in the barely literate dishwasher figuring out what I needed or didn't need and doing that for me, without my asking; and the joy of making good products and getting them out the door in time, of improvising when necessary, even when it's incredibly difficult and frustrating. (As an example: I went by the bakery today to get some baked goods, and found out that the freezers broke, so they had product sitting outside to keep it cold, and probably crammed into the downstairs freezer as well. It's the day before the busiest day of the year, and the freezers broke?!? Oy. Hard to find the joy in that, I know, but you just figure something out, because what else can you do?)

Which leads to the next point:

3. Being a chef is not only a solo gig.
Most of the competitions out there emphasize solo performance, as does this one, but cooking in a professional kitchen (or baking in a bakery) is a dance with many. Some of it is purely practical: everyone cannot have his or her own dough sheeter, for example. Yes, everyone has his or her own responsibilities, and someone who cannot perform is a drag on the whole system, and this is probably even more true in a restaurant, where people have particular stations. Yes, for the Really Big restaurants there is a visionary of some kind, someone who is doing a lot of the creating (though I would argue that part of what the visionary is doing is the marketing of the personality of the chef, not just creating "signature dishes"). But you had better be part of a team, or the whole production system will fall apart.

The Top Chef competition eliminates much of this aspect. The chefs sometimes work in "teams," but they typically still seem to produce their own items as members of that team, rather than working together or collaborating to produce a product or series of products. The two major exceptions were when the chefs were divided into two teams to produce Thanksgiving dinner for the Foo Fighters (although they still each produced their own dishes) and when everyone pitched in to help Hosea and Rahdika overcome the fact that their meats had been in an open--and therefore insufficiently cooled--fridge overnight and could not be served. The latter was just a random occurrence, but it was closer to what probably happens than any of the other more staged bits.

4. Being a chef is not only a solo gig, part 2.
The really big part of how it's not a solo gig, however, is the part where one does not just instantaneously produce The Perfect Dish. It does not happen that way. Think about how the Brazen Tart describes the dessert creation process at one of the top restaurants in this city. Think about the way we play with recipes and ingredients and write about it on our blogs (and you guys do, too). Think about how Bossman worked on formulae for his competition--over a period of a year, fer chrissakes--and how he and I both worked on items for the store. Although we might well have come up with something that we could sell the first time around (Bossman isn't big on tossing out product if someone will buy it), we'd still continue to work on it until we got it right. The competition completely eliminates one of the major major aspects of creating product--the iterations, and reiterations, and rereiterations, until the people involved feel like it's good, reproducible, and salable. I find that process to be quite interesting and fun and challenging--I liked it in school, for that matter.

How this plays into the competition is to make what they produce LESS interesting, IMHO. Tom was having a hissy fit last week about how everyone is doing "safe" stuff, and he has a point, but, dude, the way the show is set up encourages that to some extent, and the way the challenges I've seen are set up reinforces it even more. There is no time to fuck up or rethink or recover if something didn't work. Think about Eugene's soup for Martha Stewart: he had to use cornstarch to thicken it, because he didn't have enough time to let it reduce; everyone hated the cornstarch. Well, okay, yeah, I would rather not use it, either, but he had an hour to produce a fab dish for Martha, from scratch. Think about the salad that Ariane won with--not terribly interesting or exciting, but they had to come up with a dish they could produce reliably and teach on TV in 2.5 minutes. That isn't going to encourage creativity, sports fans.

On one hand, he says the point is to "win." Well, yes. So doing something interesting or risky that might not work the first time, that might need tweaking but that would rock the second or third or fourth time you tried it, isn't going to be an option when you have a total of five hours to come up with, shop for, prep, and prepare a dish. Sorry, there, Tom, but no. If you really want people to do interesting things, you have to give them the opportunity to (a) fail the first time and (b) incorporate feedback and criticism into the second (or third) time. THAT would be an interesting challenge: make a dish that meets X criteria, with the knowledge that everyone will give you feedback and you will have to incorporate the feedback into a second round of making that dish. In fact, every goddamned challenge should have a variation on that theme in it, not just the judges'-table-you-suck-or-you-rock aspect.

What would be interesting about that is how people would incorporate that feedback, quite frankly. Jamie, for example, and the blonde with the bangs (Melissa?) are really fucking annoying about that. Plus, I think that feedback thing would call out Jeff (who gets on my last fucking nerve), because he doesn't seem to think anyone has anything useful to say to him because He Is A Kitchen God. Yeah, okay, dude; did you see the part about it's just a cooking show?

I chalk all of my complaints up to a failure in conception. That is, no one is exactly clear on what a "Top Chef" actually is. What are the rules? Winning the most competitions? Not getting eliminated? Getting lucky with a particular dish when your strongest competition happens to fuck up? Those are not useful rules, and they especially are not rules that anyone could use or incorporate. compare this with What Not to Wear.

At least with WNTW there are distinct rules that the hosts try to teach, complete with explanations about why the hosts think those rules are good things. You can disagree with the rules--which I have done--but the rules are clear. The other thing with WNTW that's sort of interesting is that there's a certain lack of judgment-dispensing that's kind of refreshing. They don't tell someone OMG you're a total frump or a total slut or whatever; they say, given your body, and given the image you want to present, here are ways you can do that that will work better for you. (Aslo, on WNTW the "suspense" or the drama is manufactured sort of naturally: when the person's friends and family see her for he first time.) The same was true with "Queer Eye for the Straight Guy," which I also kind of liked.

Basically, both WNTW and QEftSG provided the participant as well as the viewer with relatively clear rules to follow, along with some rationale for doing so. Those shows were/are the equivalent of teaching someone to fish in his or her own particular pond. Top Chef is more: make fish for me! in an hour! while hopping on one foot! Which isn't that interesting, no matter what you do to tart it up.

But I'll probably watch future episodes. And be annoyed.

p.s. Larry is right, on some level, in his comment below (which I tried to say, but blogspot foiled me), except that, just looking at the recipe, I knew that it would be too greasy and too sweet, even for PB cookies, so I tried to rectify that, and I'll do so again, even if I use the chopped peanuts that Epiphenita reminds me to use.

e.t.a.: Okay, I changed the title, because some of you may not want big cursey words right there in the title, especially if the title shows up on your blog (*coughkstylecough*). You're on your own for the rest of it, though.

2 comments:

Larry Jones said...

1. My reality show is this blog.
2. You had vulgarity in your title? And I missed it? Shit.
3. This thing that Blogger has now where your blogroll is updated in real time when someone puts up a new post... I don't know if I like that.
4. Reality shows bite hard, except I kind of enjoy the ones with hot babes, but then, that's pretty much ALL television. (The Patriarchy made me say that.)

That Brazen Tart said...

A giggle Larry-ward for points 2 & 4.

Awesome rant. I agree with you point for point, but still watch the show every week. However, I Tivo it, fast-forward through all the silly interpersonal shit, and just watch the cooking parts. It saves time and actually changes the show, makes it a little more like Iron Chef.