Saturday, March 7, 2009

The Business

As I knew she would, the Brazen Tart had some interesting contributions to the cook/chef discussion. By those lights, then Fabio is actually one of the best chefs on the show, because, during Restaurant Wars, he practically single-handedly saved his team's ass. (His memorable comment, as he put on a jacket to prepare for running the front of the house, was that you could give him monkey ass and an empty clam shell and he could sell it.) The judges even told his team's ostensible leader, Leah, that she would have been going home if their team hadn't won, because her dish sucked--that is, Fabio managed to sell monkey ass. Conversely, when Carla was having difficulty getting her dessert out because the freezers weren't actually freezing anything, Radhika didn't say, for example, well, let's call it chilled soup, or otherwise suggest a solution to the problem.

Arguably, that's marketing more than being a chef, but it's partly because Fabio understands that the whole enterprise is an experience (I'm not surprised that he has his own restaurant). It's about the food, most definitely, but it's also the experience. (One of the things I have enjoyed so much about going to one of the city's best restaurants--one of the places I went for my birthday last year--was that even though I was being served world-class food, I wasn't treated with an attitude. I have been there three times now, and the experience has been the same.) By these same standards, we shouldn't be surprised that at the farm, the team of Stefan, Carla, and Jamie were the team that nailed it: three strong cooks, and at least two people (Stefan and Carla) own catering businesses, which means they should have at least some chef abilities. All of their food was good and there was no drama.

The biggest problems with the industry as a whole, though, are that it's brutally difficult work and the pay is generally for shit. BT probably has one of the highest-paid pastry cook positions in this city, in that she gets a decent wage (and that's decent by industry standards, which is a whole other thing), plus she gets benefits, including health insurance and free hotel rooms around the world. At the bakery, I made $4-$5/hour less than she did, with no health insurance, and my benefits consisted of 80 hours of pay after I'd worked there a year (i.e., a two-week "vacation" that I opted to take as pay rather than as days off). People who work in restaurants probably were even worse off than I was (I was actually treated pretty well by some industry standards). At BT's place, however, the front-of-the-house staff, i.e., the servers, can make several hundred dollars a night in tips; this is not shared with the people who actually make the food. Thus, the restaurant world is much like the industries in which I have worked, i.e., the people doing "marketing" (the servers) make a big wad more than the people making the product or doing the actual work behind the scene. (I can't even say "marketing" without sneering a little.) Although, to be fair, salespeople also take the brunt of the shit from customers. Someone in the kitchen fucks up? It's the server who hears about it, not the cook who wasn't paying attention--that is, I am most assuredly NOT harshing on servers or salespeople; it's not work I do happily, though I can do it reasonably well if I think it's a good product. (Marketing people, though, ew.)

Part of the problem in doing this kind of analysis, though, is that there are so many different pieces and levels to the whole thing. The bakery was not a pastry kitchen--and it's a small business, not part of a large corporate entity, so Bossman could not operate at a loss. And, while he seemed to be doing reasonably well, he wasn't rolling in profit and he worked his own ass off. Here's the thing, though, that gets at BT's point: while Bossman had to operate as a "chef," i.e., he had to expedite things and run things, he could also operate as a cook, i.e., he still got to make stuff, which is the part he absolutely loves. He tried to make the team for--and eventually won--an international competition because he likes trying to make the products. I know that one of the things he liked about having me around is that that's what I liked, too, and, really, that's why I wanted own a bakery (especially if BT was a partner in the enterprise).

Bossman especially liked making products that sell. And that actually brings to mind a good example (and one of my lasting contributions to the bakery). There are always scraps when you make croissants--the edges and pieces that result when you cut and shape the dough. You don't want to throw it out, especially when it's made with 100% butter the way ours were. Bossman had me throwing a couple of chunks into the next day's dough, as a kind of sourdough-starter principle. Unfortunately, especially when I was making thousands, I'd end up with more scraps than I could use, and I could rarely get the night guys to use it in the doughnut dough or the danish dough. The scraps were affecting the quality of the dough. So I suggested we chop it up with cinnamon and sugar and make monkey buns. (We also tried a cheese one, which didn't really work, and a chocolate-cherry one, which a few people liked but which didn't sell.) We started using the large muffin tins, with muffin liners, but they tended to stick to the tins, which was a complete pain. Bossman had the idea of using these little standalone paper pans--you can get them in different shapes and sizes, and they're generally used for things like brioche and pannetone--and he measured the muffin tins to figure out the right size to get. Then we experimented with how much dough to put in. Then we figured out how to run the dough down the belt with the cutter and guillotine so we'd get squares of rolled out cinnamon-and-sugar-covered croissant-dough scraps. I kept a hotel pan in the reach-in freezer and threw my scraps in there, and once a week I'd thaw it and make monkey buns. They absolutely flew off the shelves, particularly at the farmers' markets.

I typed "money buns" up there, and that turns out to be pretty accurate. We solved the problem of what to do with the scraps by creating a product with them that makes money and that the customers love. For a small-business owner, that's the fucking holy grail. For a restaurant like BT's, I doubt it makes any difference, though I could be wrong.

Anyway.

Some quick notes for all of our "friends" over there on the right:

1. Go ahead and let Rush be your spokesperson. Please; really. I can't think of a better way to demonstrate how out of touch your party is with the people who are losing their jobs and houses and life savings and health insurance. Plus, he's giving Jon Stewart some fabulous material.

2. Please try, again, to understand the concept of a marginal tax rate, okay? And please try to get it through your brains that the highest marginal tax rate is still substantially lower than it was under several recent Republican presidents.

3. Those of you who keep threatening to "go Galt"? When, exactly, are you leaving? And will you be using roads built by the government to get there? Has your magic electricity generator been perfected yet? Who's going to build the factories and equipment you're going to use to grow food and deliver it? What are you going to do for water? Because surely you don't want to sully yourselves with anything that has the taint of a public works project, do you? You'll be constructing barrels to catch rain, perhaps? Who's going to make the barrels? And so on. But really, go ahead and leave, and don't take with you anything that you haven't made with your own two soft, pasty, overpaid hands.

ETA: One of the things I have observed in at least three different industries at this point is the fact that our ostensible meritocracy, piled on top of the managerial/hierarchical way we think about work (thank you for nothing, Mr. Taylor . . .), means that the only way people can make more money is to move up a ladder, even if the upward movement takes them away from the work at which they excel and that they may well love. Do you really want to turn great teachers into principals? Do you really want to turn great counselors into clinical supervisors or managers? Do you really want to turn great cooks into chefs who rarely cook a thing? No, you don't, but if you overvalue "management" and undervalue the people who do the actual work, then that's what you get. Nobody wins.

No comments: