Monday, June 27, 2011

The Takeaway Was . . .

My antipathy toward kumbayfuckingyah activities is well-documented and longstanding. Nothing I experienced last week has caused me to change my mind. I won't get into my objections to the day's events that were specific to our organization; those are internal, and a function of the work we're doing now to merge some service bits together. And I won't even object to some of the other training sessions I've had to attend recently; while they didn't do much for me, they clearly seemed to be valuable to many other people, and I don't want to harsh that. Sometimes you just have to sit through shit and do your best not to put a damper on other people's experience. I didn't succeed in that nearly as well as I would have liked, and I admit that it's a challenge for me, and one on which I truly feel I need to work.

However.

Two things in particular highlighted my opposition. The first thing was in relation to the afternoon's "team-building" exercise. Even though the team that I was on actually won (despite have two people, me being one of them, with official Bad Attitudes about the whole thing), I found the whole thing to be completely tedious and, more important, a complete fucking waste of time. I tried very hard not to let my attitude fuck up other people's chances to win, and, in fact, it could be argued that one of my contributions was instrumental in our winning. And I still think it was a complete fucking waste of time. Why?

Because teams don't get "built" by forcing people to work together on some stupid, pointless task. Every last person, except, of course, our would-be Galtian would-be overlords, recognizes that nearly everything we do is a group effort. Even my dissertation, which, of course, I had to actually write, relied on many other people for help, advice, a sounding board, etc., and those pieces were, in fact, crucial to my being able to write a goddamned dissertation. Should their names go on it as co-authors? Well, no, probably not, given the way we think about these things, and given that, without me, that particular piece of scholarship would not have occurred. But I absolutely believe that others' contributions were vital to my being able to do it.

Back to my point: the whole afternoon's exercise was just stupid and pointless. It accomplished nothing. Nothing was gained. No teams were built. We would have spent our time better if we had come together to take a crack at some of the issues the organization is actually trying to address, rather than what we did, and people would have ended up with a greater sense of real accomplishment.

My second serious opposition was to a different activity during the day, one wherein a speaker came in and talked about changes, and how to deal with them, and blahblahfuckingblah. S/he had a particular Model Of Change (of course), which was simplistic and not at all how I think about these things, but whatevs. I could suffer through that part by stressing about all the writing that wasn't getting done on the thing that is due this Friday and not listening much to the speaker. The thing that put me over the edge, though, was that each table was supposed to use this Model to write down some change in the past year that we experienced, and to analyze the change in terms of the Model.

I absolutely refused to do it.

I didn't say anything, but I didn't fill out my notecard, and I didn't say anything when we were all supposed to be Discussing It In Our Groups. I try, as best I can, not to piss too much on what others are doing, and, hey, maybe some people get something out of shit like that; not my place to say, and good on them if they do.

But I am profoundly uncomfortable talking about made-up shit like that, in groups of people at work. I will tell people very intimate things. I have had some very deep discussions with all kinds of coworkers. I share all kinds of shit. Nevertheless, I repeat, I am profoundly uncomfortable doing this kind of pseudo-group-therapy. I hate it. I think it's worse than pointless, and I have no interest in babbling about this shit to the people with whom I work. I think it's demeaning and degrading, and I think it's a distraction from the true issues that we face, from the true elephants in the room that everyone's ignoring.

Meanwhile, I spent substantial parts of Saturday and Sunday in my office, and today was nearly a 12-hour day and tomorrow and Wednesday are likely to be similar. In fact, I'll be lucky if it's just tomorrow and Wednesday, and not an all-nighter on Thursday as well.

Other than that? The kumbaifuckingyah event was wonderful.

No comments: