Sunday, October 9, 2011

All of Us

I hadn't been paying much attention to "occupy Wall Street"--in part because the news media weren't paying attention to it, and in part because I don't pay much attention to the news beyond the front page of the NY Times. But last night I stumbled across this site, started by two of the people who started the occupy Wall Street effort. (There's an article on the Mother Jones site about the creators.) And it nearly brought me to tears--it's every Springsteen song about hard luck and hard times.

It made me think of my own luck, and the luck the rest of my family shares. I've told you about my mom's new kidney, and my dad's onoing bladder cancer treatment, and my dad's quadruple bypass surgery, and my mom's back surgery that fused seven of her vertebrae. Why aren't my parents crippled by debt from all that health care? Not because they're wealthy--it's because my dad, thanks to his union, has excellent health insurance. Without that, my parents would be poor, or dead, or both, and that is all because my dad was a union member for 40-some years.

Thanks in part, again, to my dad's union membership, my parents were able to save money, and invest it. (Yes, there was a certain amount of hard work in there, and saving--and, again, luck: my dad didn't become disabled on the job, and he was able to work until retirement age, at a job that paid a good wage.) Thus, when my sister-in-law didn't pay the mortgage for more than a year, my parents were able to help my brother and SIL keep their house. When I've gone through bouts of grad school and unemployment, my parents have been able to help me out, too. (When I was in grad school, that extra couple hundred bucks meant that I could eat a little better, and maybe have a beer once in awhile.) In neither case was it the kind of "help" that trust fund kids get, but it was just enough.

Just enough so Bro and SIL were able to keep the house, and pay off their consumer debts, and start over without having to either lose everything or be saddled by crippling debt for the rest of their lives. Just enough so that I never truly worried about starving--moving back in with my parents when I was in my mid-30s (or mid-40s) would not have been the least bit desirable, but I did not have to worry about becoming homeless.

I've been able to pay off my debts, too--three rounds of student loans!--but it's all so precarious. Suppose, for example, that when they got rid of my boss last year they decided to get rid of me, too--six months after I took on a mortgage. Finding a job in this economy is a nightmare, and finding one that would enable me to keep my home--in which I had put nearly all my savings--might have been impossible.

There are other parts to the luck, too: my parents didn't just throw money at my brother's problems, they were also knowledgeable enough to sit down and consolidate the debt and get a lower interest rate (by cosigning, I think). Someone who doesn't have access to that form of help is going to get in trouble all over again, even if the immediate cash need is met; more likely, they'll get just enough out of the hole to stay afloat and keep paying exorbitant interest rates on any credit they get.

So, even though I make a decent living, and can enjoy myself a bit, I, too, am one of the 99%. And the good luck I've experienced isn't entirely luck. Some of it is that my father made a good living working with his hands--thanks to a union. Some of it is that my parents didn't have to deal with any major financial crises. Some of it is that my mother's parents earned and saved a little, too, along the way, Some of it is that we were all able to work hard, and we have done that--no crippling medical conditions; no mental illness; no disabling accidents.
Some of it is that I was able to go to a good college, and end up with less than $5k of debt, thanks to government programs (and thanks to having a sister who was only two years behind me in school, so we both ended up with more financial aid than if we'd gone separately).

But that list isn't so outrageous. It should not be beyond the reach of most people. People should be able to start over, either out of choice or necessity. (Suppose you're in a terrible marriage for 30 years and your spouse spends every nickel and you have kids and can't or don't quite want to or don't know how to get out of that situation, and now you're nearly 50 and divorced and have no savings and you lose your job, or even are just stuck in a job that pays enough to live on, and gives you health insurance, but you can barely get by. Suppose your partner runs up debts that you dont find out about until it's too late, and your name is attached to that debt, too. Suppose you buy a house and don't use it as a cash machine and take all the equity out, but you lose your job and your adjustable rate goes up and now you can't pay the bills, even though you found another job--at a third less money--because you had to live on credit cards for awhile, after you drained your savings.

I could come up with a thousand more scenarios, because they're all out there. The thing is, money isn't a good in itself. Money insulates us from disaster. (For the 1%, it buys big homes and private schools and yachts and European trips or whatevs, but for us, it's insulation.) Money means, if you make a mistake--even a stupid one, like your spouse isn't paying the mortgage but writes it in the checkbook, so you don't find out for more than a year, and then only because a coworker saw in the paper that your house is up for a sheriff's sale--you're not completely doomed. Money means if you have to start over, you can come up with the security deposit and moving expenses for a decent apartment. Money means that you can get medical care if you need it--and medical insurance, in case something big and expensive comes along. And none of these amounts of money would be a pimple on the ass of the 1%, but all these amounts of money are the difference between having a life and barely clinging to the edge of the abyss for the other 99% of us.

1 comment:

Larry Jones said...

Thank you for writing this.

I think we -- all of us -- have been slow to wake up to what's happening because we are, after all, Americans: We are in charge of the whole world, we can do anything, we are the best ever.

And so it has been difficult for us as a people to see the creeping corporate takeover of the nation, and the enslavement of the population. I've been in a dead-end job for twenty years, and while I've complained about it, I thought it was my own fault until recently. For the past five years I've actually been grateful for the low pay, because it's better than what many of my coworkers got, which was fired. Thanks to OWS I now see I'm not alone.

I hope the Occupiers stay with it, and I hope their numbers grow. They don't need a list of demands or a policy statement, not yet. The heartbreaking statements on the site you linked to are enough for now. It's about time these things came out. It's about time we looked around and saw our neighbors struggling against a rigged system.

The power structure has overreached. No one wants to kill them or take all their money, but they must -- and they will -- realize that they cannot have everything.