Time for another edition of Narya's Pet Peeves!
You may remember that my ex-in-laws had celiac disease (and a couple also couldn't do dairy, and one couldn't do soy or corn, either). I even had fantasies, for awhile, of having not one but two bakeries, one of which would have been gluten-free. (That particular fantasy required major lottery winnings.) It's a pain to manage it, though one gets used to it, and they did a great job of it. They own a store, as a matter of fact, that is all gluten-free, and they do a lot of mail-order business as well. I suspect they'll continue to face ever-stiffer competition, as many regular grocery stores are increasing their GF options dramatically. They have also been quite active in various celiac identification efforts. The condition seems to be on the rise, and not just because it was being under-diagnosed, though that's also the case. (I have my own suspicions about the increase, but I'll get back to them in a second.) Point being, I have a fair amount of close personal experience with people who really must avoid gluten at all costs; it's practically a poison for them.
None of this makes me peevish. In fact, I have a great deal of sympathy for people with celiac disease. As a result of hanging with them for the time I was with Chuck, I was able to see, first-hand, just how difficult it can be to get food one feels safe eating. It requires constant vigilance, particularly when going out to restaurants--even ones that claim to have gluten-free menus or options. If you throw the dairy-free needs on top of the gluten-free, like my ex bro-in-law, it can be a complete nightmare. Yes, Virginia, butter counts as dairy, so those veggies need to be steamed, or sauteed in oil (and, in his case, not corn oil).
Lately, though, I've been running into people who are claiming they are going without gluten, even though they're not celiac, because they have some idea that gluten is bad for them. They don't provide any evidence other than anecdata--somebody suggested it to them, possibly even a doctor, but no, they haven't been tested for celiac disease, or they've been tested and are negative. They've "heard" that gluten is inflammatory or something. Even this only mildly irritates me: people can eat what they want (even if their choices are stoopid). I'm seriously irritated by the lack of evidence for their claims, and suspect that the problems aren't with gluten, but whatevs.
What really puts me around the bend are people who claim that they're going "gluten-free" and then have something with gluten in it. Look, people: either you're gluten-free or you're not. If you are, then that Danish isn't something you can eat, and you had best be reading the labels of the salad dressing and every other damn thing. Gluten-free doesn't mean gluten-free-except-for-things-I-really-like. It means gluten-free soy sauce, and beer, and pasta, and all kinds of other stuff. It means that you can eat oats, but only if they haven't been contaminated by being grown too close to wheat. It means no bread, unless it's gluten-free. It means constant vigilance, not occasional dalliance. If you want to dally with gluten-free, that's fine, too, but then keep it to yourself. So, yes, this is an irritation to me: if you really want to do without gluten, well, okay, I'm not going to force you to eat my whole-grain, crusty, tasty bread, any more than I would try to force a vegetarian to eat meat. But then actually do without gluten, not just dabble in avoiding it. I may roll my eyes a little (secretly, and only if you're not actually celiac), but if it works for you and it helps you eat more healthy food, hey, go for it.
But I have a sneaking suspicion that a lot of the supposed gluten sensitivity is related to the over-processed crap that many people eat. Industrial food--like the food outlined in the first sectoin of "The Omnivore's Dilemma," for example--isn't healthy food; it's fuel, for an industrial cog, i.e., the workers. (Yes, I realize I sound like a Wobbly.) I also suspect that the flours used in industrial food fuck with the gluten in the food in ways that may well be unhealthy without causing celiac disease. That's not a problem with gluten per se, but with the industrial agriculture and manufacturing processes.
I realize that many people don't have much choice; if you're poor, you need as many cheap calories as you can get. I can shudder at the thought of the "meat" product in fast-food tacos or hamburgers, but I'm also, despite my unemployed state, much more financially able to make different choices. Even people who don't need to maximize their calories per dollar are besieged by shiny packages and convenience foods and, if they didn't grow up seeing someone cook from scratch, they're less likely to see that as something they can do. People get overwhelmed, and I understand that: I'm more annoyed by the producers of that crap than by the people who eat it out of necessity or even out of desire.
And I think a lot of the "gluten is bad" that's in the ether these days is a result of the same industrial food machine. It's a new market, a new way to sell Product. Take some half-baked data fragment and inflate it into a full-blown epidemic, one that can only be treated by going on this new (expensive, of course) diet and buying these (expensive) products. It helps the people who really do need a gluten-free diet by making more foods available for them, but that's incidental; the real aim is to create a whole other market for the products.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
Nice blog, Narya.
Selection pressure is off. My bad eyes would have meant early death in older societies, yet here I am middle aged with a wondrous bad eyed child. These allergies are similar. In a couple generations, when things get tough, it's going to get super ugly.
And gluten? Love it! Few things nicer on the nose than working a ball of dough until it gets rubbery, then baking up a treat.
I've thought about my own miserable eyesight in the same terms; I trip over furniture. I am really coming to think that the allergies are like global warming: we can reverse some of it, if we change some of what we're doing in fairly dramatic ways, and some of it will be with us no matter what.
Thanks for visiting--I like your commentary at Susan's!
It's a new market, a new way to sell Product.
Bingo.
I keep thinking that a/ It's nice that more stuff is easy to get for people who need it; b/ It's amazing how fast this has gone from Marin County Virtue Fad(tm) to Marketable; c/ This Year's Yeast/Fat/Cholesterol/NameYerPoison, again.
Oh yeah: and Lo-Fat vs Atkins.
You live through a few of these, and a pattern emerges. Kinda like pants waistlines.
And I'd like some of that bread, please.
Post a Comment