Sunday, January 14, 2007

Gimme a C

The amount of delusion of which some people are capable is a little disturbing. Take, for example, cheerleading. Either it's a sport on its own (which some people claim, pointing to the more gymnastic examples of the activity, even though such examples aren't typical of most cheerleading squads), which raises questions of its own, or it's not a sport, but a means of cheering on the school's athletic teams. If the latter, then why should only boys' teams get cheers? (And why should only girls be cheerleaders, our current president notwithstanding?) And why can't the writer of the article, or, apparently, most of the people in the article, see that? If the point is to cheer on the school's athletic teams, then they should all get cheered on. How difficult a point is that to understand?

But, of course, no one can come right out and say that the cheerleaders are supporting the boys, that they're practicing to be sexbots, and cheering for girls gets in the way of that sexbot role. The cheerleaders themselves don't want to cheer for icky girls; they want to cheer (and display their wares) for boys, or what's the point of being a cheerleader? The most unintentionally entertaining comment was the last one of the article, where the cheerleader lamented the "extra work" involved and declared that interest would keep dropping, "until there's no cheerleading any more." And why, exactly, would that be a bad thing?

I also like the inherent philosophical dilemma in declaring that cheerleading is a sport all on its own. That is, people who make that claim frequently point to the competitive cheerleading squads, the ones you see on ESPN2 when they're short of programming. But do those squads actually cheer for teams? Are they ever on the sidelines? If not--and I truly don't know--then that's just ridiculous in a whole other way.

7 comments:

kStyle said...

OH MY GOD CHEERLEADING.

maybe the girls who dropped out can still apply for a pageant on time.

Narya said...

Yeah, the thing that's most entertaining (in a depressing way) is that the "journalist" didn't think to ask anyone what, exactly, the problem with cheering for girls' teams is. "Why don't you want to cheer for girls' teams? Are they less representative of the school's athletic endeavors somehow?" No one would answer it honestly, of course, but it would be interesting nonetheless.

kStyle said...

Word.

*sigh*

kStyle said...

Ah-ha, yes! I remember what I meant to tell you. My mom was a cheerleader in h.s. and college.

In a similar situation to the one described in the article--the other college cheerleaders didn't want to cheer for the soccer team, because it was filled with short, Portuguese guys. Isn't that awful? If I remember correctly, my mom had a big fight with the other head cheerleader about this; she rightly insisted that they were there to cheer for all the teams.

Later, she married a Portuguese guy, but not one from the team, which I think is a cute addendum to the story.

Narya said...

I didn't say, but should have, that my mother was also a cheerleader in high school and, I believe, for the two years she was in college (Associate's degree for mom). And my sister was on the drill team, which she eventually captained. Needless to say, I'm not from the same gene pool on this subject.

Narya said...

And good on your mom, too.

Orange said...

But you must not overlook the career-training benefits of collegiate cheerleading. Pharmaceutical companies contact cheerleading coaches to recruit drug reps (those people in suits who sidle right into the doctor's office as you fester in the waiting room). Why? Because they're so good at persuading people to be happy with them, so they'll prescribe the drug manufacturer's wares. I have a cousin who (a) was on one of those ESPN-contest-caliber cheer squads and (b) worked as a drug rep.

Cheerleading is also important in that it helps maintain those patriarchally approved norms for girly short skirts and whatnot.