Thursday, January 4, 2007

Lipstick, Again

I should be editing, but I simply cannot face it tonight. After ten hours at work (excuse me; that should be 10 hours), I shlepped around to two 2 bookstores in search of (a) 2 calendars a friend wanted and couldn't find downtown and (b) a good guide to Quickbooks. I managed to find one of the two calendars and the guide, plus I scored some Far Side calendars (one for me, one for the friend--who said he'd had it in his hand about three times but never committed; I made the decision for him). It was pouring rain, so by the time I got home, I managed to finish editing one chapter and eat some crackers, and then I gave up. The wine called, and I answered.

I've been thinking about makeup a lot lately. A few cosmetics-related brawls have broken out over at Twisty's over the past year, and a huge number of women have defended (for lack of a better verb) the use of cosmetics rather vehemently, primarily on three grounds: (1) they're mostly harmless decoration, used in a spirit of fun and play, and humans have used them that way for a long time, so what's the big deal; (2) I feel better when I wear them--which might be patriarchally induced, but so what; (3) I work in a field/office/environment where I really must fit in, else I'll be denied promotions, etc., and makeup is part of what is expected of women. No one at Twisty's seems to argue that all women should wear makeup, however, and there are different degrees of all of the above defenses. What's also fascinating to me is the stories behind the defenses: my personal favorite is the commenter who grew up in a very patriarchal, old-fashioned-religion household, such that makeup is actually a subversion of the patriarchy that raised her, even if it's directly in keeping with the patriarchy of the rest of society. The other thing about makeup is that it doesn't necessarily damage anything--spike heels, for example, will cause bunions and foot problems and possibly shorten your calf muscles, if you wear them all the time, and you'd better not have to move quickly in them at any time. But makeup doesn't do that.

My personal history on this is sort of odd, too (there's a shock). I wore some in high school, but it wasn't an approved item around my house, so not a lot. I didn't in college--didn't own any, if I remember correctly--and also stopped shaving my body hair then. When I was working in Philadelphia, one of the women with whom I worked encouraged/badgered me to wear it, and I did. It seemed pretty harmless, and it served as a counter-signal to the hairy legs. (That is, in a patriarchy, women have to provide some signals that they're . . . I don't know. Acceptable? Not feminists? Not shrill? Not uncompromising? Whatever the fuck the insult of the day is.) I think I wore some in grad school, but not a whole lot. Once I was working after grad school, I wore it pretty consistently: mascara, eye shadow, blush, lipstick. I pretty much only put it on in the morning--constant touchups were never my thing--but I did wear it daily during the week, and I'd put on a little if Chuck and I went out on Sunday night, say. Since I changed professions again, however, I almost never wear it. I certainly don't wear it to work--it would be bizarre in this environment. If I'm going out to dinner, say, I might wear some, but I bet it doesn't happen more than three or four times a month, if that, and I've gone out without it.

In other words, I don't really have strong feelings about it one way or the other. i recognize the usefulness of it, if I want to (appear to) fit in in particular ways, but I don't feel naked without it, either. I'd probably feel a little strange working in a professional environment, especially if I had a visible or middle/upper management position, if I didn't wear any at all, but probably no stranger than I'd feel wearing it at my current job. A lot of other women seem to have much stronger feelings about it, though, and I wonder why. I also suspect that, were all makeup to disappear overnight, a number of people would go about reinventing it, and I don't think all of that has to do with patriarchy. That is, I think we do have a decorative urge. What we think "looks good" may be socially and patriarchally constructed (and I think aesthetic taste is, in many ways, constructed/learned), but the decorative urge is still there. That is, we all want to decorate (ourselves, our environments), but the choices for decoration are constructed for us and learned by us in our societies.

So I wouldn't really mind if all makeup disappeared overnight. It's not like patriarchy would disappear with it. And, really, that's the important part here: the fact that women's looks are assessed so thoroughly and so consistently, and that how women look is regarded as a topic for discussion. We're supposed to care about it and spend time and money on it, in ways and to a degree that differ from the expectations placed on men. In other words, whether I wear lipstick is regarded as important, in multiple arenas, and for multiple reasons. I'm sure I could say this all more clearly, but I'm tired, so you all are going to have to figure it out your own selves.

7 comments:

kStyle said...

I wrote a long comment, and Blogger fucking ate it. Come see my on my blog tomorrow and we'll discuss makeup.

Good night.

Larry Jones said...

Men like to look at women, and I think you can guess that we talk about the way you look, too. I have guessed that you talk about the way we look (right?). Assuming heterosexuals of both genders here, the difference is that women also talk about the way women look, but men don't do that (talk about other men). The patriarchy, if we must use the term, may have a lot to say about what "look" is in current fashion, but I wonder if it's merely influencing an inherent interest in personal decoration that women have.

Don't hit me -- I think it was brave (albeit dumb) of me even to bring this up.

kStyle said...

Larry, I agree; hope no one hits me, either.

Narya said...

If you want to argue that women have some "natural" interest in decoration, you need to specify the mechanisms for that. And do not give me some kind of quasi-sociobiology crap, either. I don't think it was particularly brave; it's what Dr. Phil and the like say all the time, with no evidence whatsoever. It also wasn't particularly dumb. And I have a no-hitting rule, so you're safe on that count.

In addition, the patriarchy--and, yes, we must use that term--is part of the reason that women talk about how other women look but men don't talk about how other men look, and that's a whole other (related) kettle of fish.

Larry Jones said...

No, I don't have to specify the mechanism. I was suggesting a possible reason for the fact that women talk about the way other women look. Isn't it OK to try to work backward from an observation to a possible cause? If you know for a fact that it's not because they are innately more interested in decoration and makeup, why not just say the real reason? And how will I know sociobiology from quasi-sociobiology?

kStyle said...

I tend to think it's all part of an ancient mating dance, but I think the threads of history, biology, sociology, and gender are so tangled up that it's all but impossible to untangle them.

Or something. I don't really know.

I'm better at women's drum circles than I am to debates about feminist things. :(

Orange said...

There's plenty of generalizing going on in this comments box. I do know men who acknowledge (at least to female friends) noticing other men's looks. And I'm skeptical that women have an "innate" interest in adornment. I know men who pay more attention to fashion and hair products than my closest women friends.

Me, I quit eye makeup in my 20s because it always made my eyes water and I never thought my eyes looked better with shadow, liner, and mascara. Sensitive skin means I stick to an SPF 15 or 30 lotion in lieu of "foundation" or "base makeup" or whatever it's called, with a dab of green powder to tone down rosacea redness. Occasionally use a wee dab of Dermablend to hide a zit (this is a new thing for me). And I haven't used blush in over a decade (see: rosacea). I blow-dry my hair a little to keep my bangs from lying utterly flat and lifeless, but don't use mousse/gel/hairspray. I did start going to an expensive salon for cuts and highlights (to hide the gray!). I think in general expensive cosmetics and grooming are a tool of the patriarchy—any 24-year-old in a starter job who's buying Chanel cosmetics and fancy eye creams is frittering away money better tucked away in a 401(k). But I can afford my hair salon, so I don't think it's a harmful habit. (And I've told the stylist—a Frenchman!—that I won't be doing an intricate blow-dry and I won't be using products on my hair, so I need a totally low-maintenance haircut. Lasts for months!)

Sorry, am I rambling here? I just finished editing a paper, so I feel entitled...