I had all kinds of ambitious plans for this evening, mostly involving editing another chapter of the textbook, and, who knows, I may actually do more of that. But first? A rant.
Because of the state in which I live, I don't actually have to vote for Obama. He will almost certainly take this state no matter what I do; it's not even close. If it were close, I would, in fact, likely vote for him, and I still may. He is way more conventional than his adulators seem to realize--his health care plan sucked and blew, he has yet to put forth a true populist message, he mouths platitudes with little evidence that there's much there there.
However, he has pissed me off mightily in the past two weeks, first with his pandering to the godpeople. I do not, in fact, think that "faith-based" organizations are all that and a ball of cheese. You want to worship a deity? Or more than one? Have at it. If you want to study old texts for clues to how you should behave? I don't really have a problem with that, either. Hey, if you want to believe that the deity(ies) of your choice wrote or inspired those texts, I don't even care about that. But leave me out of it, okay? I do not think that such textual interpretation and related worshipping behavior should (a) exempt your organization from paying taxes, or (b) serve as some kind of be-all, end-all guide for everyone else's behavior, or (c) serve as the basis for a form of government.
I'm willing to allow non-profit organizations that actually provide services to people to get tax breaks, and if an arm of your deity's organization provides such services, well, that arm should get appropriate tax breaks. But a blanket exemption for religions? Not so much. And, more to the point, I do not think that FBOs have some special ability to provide human services, and I do not think they should be privileged in terms of getting my tax dollars to provide such services.
But this latest thing has me spitting. Via digby (who also provides some useful history about abortion politics in this country) here's an article about it, and here's a followup. He said, basically, that after 22 weeks, there shouldn't be much of a "mental health" exception. As the article notes, he thinks mental health exceptions can be "'rigorously' limited to only those women with 'serious clinical mental health diseases.' He said mental health exceptions are not intended [to] permit abortions when a woman simply 'doesn't feel good.' 'It is not just a matter of feeling blue,' Obama said."
You know what? Fuck that. Seriously. Who the fuck does he think gets to decide if a woman is in bad enough shape to "deserve" an abortion? And does he realize that the anti-choice brigades and the anti-contraception brigades have made it more difficult for women to get knowledge about pregnancy and contraception, access to reliable contraception, and access to safe, early-term abortions when that fails? This is such an epic fail that I really don't know whether I'll vote for him--how do I know that he wouldn't nominate a justice like Thomas or Scalia--who are the two who share his views on this issue? Because that's supposed to be--and, in many ways, is--the reason to vote for him, if all else fails.
Yes, I understand that his economic policies will supposedly be better than McSame's, and he'll likely get us out of Iraq sooner, but to just write off more than half the population of the country? To say that someone else gets to decide whether I bear a child? That, my friend, is forced pregnancy. And that line about "not just a matter of feeling blue." Fuck that. Because women are all la-di-da about the whole thing, and just randomly decide to wait until the end of the second trimester to have an abortion? Uh, no, asshole. Tell you what; why not actually talk to a bunch of women who terminated pregnancies after 22 weeks? (Good luck--they are a tiny percentage of the abortions performed.) And then sit there and tell me why someone other than those women should get a say in the matter. The issues involved aren't "feeling blue," and I'm appalled that he would characterize it that way.
That, in fact, is a huge part of my dismay. The people who choose an abortion at that late date are going through a pile of crap, I guarantee you; it's not that they were "feeling blue." And to even characterize it that way trivializes every last aspect of it, and, once again, strips from women their bodily integrity and the assumption that they can be trusted to make decisions about their own lives and their own welfare. So bite me, dude.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
I agree with everything you've said here, especially the tax-exempt religion thing. I have never understood why churches don't have to pay taxes. It doesn't make any sense.
Also, the more financial aid goes to faith-based organizations, the fewer grants there are for secular organizations, like the child care nonprofit for which I currently work. And we're already on a tight budget, which means not enough help for families that need it.
As for the abortion thing...oof. In response to criticism he said something like, "Well, I was really saying something entirely different," except he didn't clarify his beliefs on the matter at all. And to blame others for "misinterpreting" something that was perfectly clear seems kind of weasely to me. I mean, I know he's a politician, but for crying out loud.
This entire election has been making me ill for some time now. I still don't know if I'm going to vote third-party or just against McCain. Either way, I'm not a happy citizen.
I knew there would be some disappointments about Obama when he started running in the general election, and I tried to get ready. But this and other "moves to the center" are getting hard to take. I don't think there is any real choice, of course, but what else is new in American politics?
He is a politician, and I think it's safe to say, since he's running for the highest office, an egomaniac, too. He'll do his best to win rural, religious and right-side voters. But from his family background, his obvious intelligence, his history of street-level organizing, I'm hoping he turns out to be more than just an image.
I actually think he IS more than an image--I just don't think he's nearly as populist or as progressive as his adulators seem to think he is. I don't object to the image, or even the image-mongering--I object to his actual policies/beliefs. And the only reason the "change" message works at all is because of the current administration; it would have played less well against, say, his father.
Howdy, epi! glad you came by!
Post a Comment