In a wonderful, thoughtful, blurty post, kstyle touches on a bunch of issues that have been floating in my brain for months. (And I may have written part of this here, so pardon me if I'm repeating again.) Warning: this is kind of all over the place rather than aiming for a single specific point.
At one point this summer, I walked home from work. Although I live in a neighborhood that is populated by gentrifiers as well as by working-class and poor people, by students and drug dealers and old hippies--i.e., in a neighborhood that has a mix of people and housing stock--the path from work is through one of the older, more wealthy suburbs around this city. (A little further north of where I work you can find one of the richest burbs in the country; we go through it on the way to the outdoor music venue.) What this meant is that I was walking through one of the country's richest suburbs, past old, well-maintained lakefront mansions. In my chef clothes. After earning somewhere around $100, before taxes, for 10 hours of hard physical work.
It put me in a viciously bad mood, and anger at myself was no small part of it. I was looking at these houses and feeling resentful and unhappy--not because I particularly want those houses, mind you (and I'll get back to that in a second), but because, even were I to want one, it is completely and totally out of my reach. I don't work any less hard than the people who live there, I'm no less smart, the work that I do is no less useful (or, at least, I don't think it is), but nothing I have ever done or am ever likely to do will provide me with the means to own one of those houses--or, possibly, any property at all. And I was angry at myself for that covetousness, and for that resentment; I really don't like feeling that way, and I find it shameful and embarrassing that I cared enough about it to get myself worked up about it. But I've been thinking about it for months, trying to tease the various bits out of it.
As noted, I wouldn't want one of those houses, and that isn't sour grapes on my part. In the northern, richer suburbs, the houses on the lake make the houses past which I was walking look small. Some of them are uglier than shit--McMansions, or nearly so, or just plain big and stupid and ugly, with lots of architectural flourishes that serve no function--but some are quite beautiful, and they are nearly all on acres and acres of land. But if I had one of those places, who would maintain it? Yes, I know, those people don't mow their own lawns, do their own laundry, or (literally or figuratively) clean up their own shit, but I'm working-class enough such that it just seems wrong, somehow, to have so much space that one can't maintain it oneself. (And, as if to mock me, an issue of the Nature Conservancy magazine from around that time featured a board member from one of those suburbs. She loves to fly-fish, and she has probably donated big wads of money to protect lands that might otherwise be destroyed or industrialized, i.e., not everyone who lives in those burbs is a self-satisfied, greedy fuck, and in fact some people use that money for the betterment of the world.) That is, living in such a mansion would require such a change of being for me as to probably cause my head to spin around and around.
I also know, from my brief sojourn in the land of the (for me) well-paid, that having (for me) a lot of money doesn't mean I go spend it all on Stuff. Despite the occasional indulgence in consumer toys--hello, iPod--and an improved wardrobe (some of which was necessary, given the fact that much of my clothing was still from grad school or before), I discovered that I didn't go buy lots of Things and I still looked to buy things on sale. Even the new computer is in part justified (or rationalized?) by the fact that, if I do end up doing the editing work full time, I want to be more mobile. It was useful to have that well-paid episode, because I think it's one thing to imagine how one might act, and another thing to observe how one actually acts, i.e., I certainly was more self-indulgent, primarily with going out to dinner, because that's one of my favorite things, but I also did Responsible stuff, I upped my charitable contributions, I paid off loans early, I didn't live beyond my means, and I made it a point to save. The experience helped me recognize that, when push comes to shove, I don't particularly want a big house or a lot of stuff. I want some insulation from calamity (or, at least, the kind of insulation that money can bring); I want to be able to go grocery shopping without a running tally in my head that I compare against my bank balance or budget; I want to be able to treat (or help out) a friend or my brother.
And here's the other thing, and I'm sure I've mentioned this before: Wealth does not remove your problems. You still have to figure out your life. Wads of money can insulate you from some of that, of course, just as it can get you health care, say, but bad and sad things still happen when you're rich. You can be as aware or unaware with money as without it; you can just afford a better class of drugs, and better lawyers, and better rehab.
Unlike kstyle, however, my issues about upper classes aren't at all latent. It's not stuff-envy--I really don't want the houses or lawns or whatever; I don't want the vehicles or closets full of clothing or servants. It's that I don't trust piles of stuff. What can one possibly do with it all? (Note that I understand the line between "enough" and "too much" is wide and very, very blurry, and everyone's mileage will vary considerably, depending in part on where one lives.) I try not to impute evil thoughts to people who have lots of stuff, but part of me wonders what hole they're trying to fill with all that stuff.
Sunday, December 2, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
I suspect that once you have enough money to buy a large lakefront house, you still have so much money that it makes perfect sense to fill the house with a large quantity of spendy stuff. It's not that they feel the need to have the stuff, but what else can they do with their wealth? (I know, I know: massive donations to charity.)
We're feeling pretty flush here, but are nowhere near having the sort of money to buy one of those houses, nor even a nice duplex in the city.
I think another part of it, for me, is that I don't feel the need to live at the limit of my income (unless circumstances compel me, of course, but that's a reduced rather than large income). But, hey, I don't know. Give me big wads of money and we'll see what happens.
If you were making $600,000 a year but your mortgage, other rich-folk living expenses, retirement savings, etc., "only" ran to $450,000 a year, you'd still have a crapload of discretionary income for Stuff and vacations and donations and whatnot. I suspect many of the people in those houses may be living that sort of lifestyle rather than, say earning a mere $450,000 a year and having to spend it all.
Though bro tells of a couple with a 7-figure combined income who were turned down for a car loan first time through because they had so much debt (multiple vehicles and houses and Stuff). They got a loan and vehicle, but not at a good rate. (He saw the actual application, w/ name removed; he works at a dealership and a sales manager showed it to him.) My guess is that some people are in that category and some not.
I still say give ME that wad of money and see what I do; call it a sociology experiment.
Thanks for the shout-out.
You know, before I read your post, I remembered something I've heard from several of my Buddhist teachers--and then you said it, too. Being financially well-off doesn't mean you don't have problems. As the Ven. Lobsang says, "Do you think Bill Gates does not have worries?" As Thay says, "Imagine you are given a billion dollars right now. Would this solve all your problems?...I would have many more problems. I am a monk. I don't have a bank account!"
...And, as the venerable poets said, Mo money, mo problems.
You might tell the Ven. Lobsang that I'd gladly trade the problems I have now for the problems I'd have with that hypothetical billion. Several of the most painful things I'm carrying around now, including life/death stuff, would be or would have been solved by enough money.
Jolly that he's a monk. No attachments? Presumably no dependents, legal or otherwise. I happen to have known a dozen or so ex-nuns of the Catholic sort, and every one of them has commented on how much harder it is to have that bank account -- or to have to have it, to finance one's own life. One said she'd never been so poor as since she'd dropped that Vow of Poverty.
Yeah, I grudge at and envy the rich, and I won't pretend I don't. Not the stuff: the power.
No attachments except, perhaps, to the orphans at the all-expenses-paid school he founded for poor children in remote India, near where he grew up impoverished and his mother abandoned him for a time when he was an infant. I'm sure that he cares deeply and worries for them, so I refuse to be cynical about the Ven. Lobsang or his teachings; his life work speaks very strongly. That's the thing, the monastics I've met have by and large had very difficult lives (wars, famines, being orphaned, the list goes on) that were made better by Dharma.
I'm sorry for the stuff you're going through, though. Life really is tough in all stations of wealth and not-wealth. And a money cushion does help. But the extra yacht? Maybe not.
Post a Comment