Okay, enough.
If you haven't seen The Daily Show from Monday night, then hunt it down on the web and watch it, particularly the opening segment and the closing lines. Basically, TDS goes to Wasilla to interview so-called "real" Americans--you know: those people who live in small towns, because those of us who live in cities, even though we are the majority of the fucking country, aren't REALLY real. And the people being interviewed prattle on about how small towns are where the values really are (because the rest of us eat children for lunch and unwary rural tourists for dinner). When asked how all this realness came about, one interviewee cites 9-11. Well, the interviewer points out, that happened in New York City, to New Yorkers. For which the interviewee doesn't really have any response at all. It's like the politicians who wrap themselves in 9-11, perhaps even going to ground zero, and then leave the city and start warbling about how eeeeevil New Yorkers and all city folk really are, because small towns are where you find, you know, actual values.
And I'm really fucking sick of it. I grew up in a small town: about 18,000 people. It was the largest town in the county, and, at the time, it was surrounded by what was still farmland. There was a Future Farmers of America (all hail blue courderoy!) at my high school, and a county farmers' fair every summer. There was also industry--Ingersoll Rand had a division in town, and there was a big-pipe (like sewer-pipe-size) manufacturer. Since I lived there, the former has removed all the actual manufacturing, although the land isn't being used for anything--too much toxic waste, apparently--and the latter was bought up by a company that was featured in the NY Times a few years ago for its OSHA violations at its plants, including that one. The town is more than hundred years old, and it's tired, and there's not much work, and it's kind of down and out. The farmland has been chewed up by developments: once one farmer sells, everyone else's property values go up, even though the property and the business haven't changed, and suddenly a business that is marginal and hard work but a living becomes an impossibility, all to make way for McMansions. Because, now that a highway is in place, some people who live within 10 or 15 minutes of my hometown commute to New York and back every day.
Yes, New York and Philadelphia were within a two-hour drive, but we never went there, except for the once-a-year outing to see the Phillies and the occasional visit to the Philadelphia Zoo. We also went to the American Museum of Natural History once, I think, when my brother was little, so I must have been 11 or so.
But we didn't go to big cities; not just because some of the highways weren't there yet, but because it just wasn't part of our repertoire, and I don't think we were unusual in that. So I understand those origins, and the prejudices that breed there, as well as both the good and bad parts of a small size. When I first moved to a city, I had spent less than a month in cities ever in my life--i.e., fewer than 30 days total.
I've lived in cities, however, since 1981--i.e., for 28 years, give or take. And you know what? "Real" people live in cities, too. We live and breathe and vote and pay taxes and die here. We pay more taxes than people who live outside of cities, because cities have infrastructures, and suburbanites and rural people who visit or work in the cities use those infrastructures but don't contribute much to their upkeep. And, yes, we tend to vote Democratic, especially in this state: have you ever thought about why that would be?
Well the Republican right-wing has, and what they've concluded, apparently, is that we vote Democratic because we're unamerican.
Now, of course, for a little detour, let me point out that the right wing isn't one group of people; it's several groups:
1. There's the children of privilege--Kristol, Podheretz, Jonah Goldberg, and I'm sure there are a bunch more--whose mommies and/or daddies are right wingers, and the children are following in the footsteps. Most of them, so far as I can tell, have never worked a shit job, or anything other than a wingnut-welfare job, and they are the people I have in mind when I rant about 50-pound sacks of flour, not least because they are also the people who promulgate memes about "real" Americans. If Bill Kristol is more "real" than I am, then I am Marie of Romania.
2. There's the Rovian rat-fuckers who learned their trade at the knee of the Nixonian rat-fuckers (that was their term of art). They are the people in charge of smearing and sliming and insinuating, of developing and utilizing as many dirty tricks as they can invent or recycle. They've never met a Democratic vote they don't want to suppress or invalidate in some way. It's not entirely clear to me what they get out of it, because they typically don't start out or end up as rich or powerful; they do the dirty work, and it's a good-paying job, but they're not going to get really big bucks, and I think they tend to be held at arms' length by much of the rest of the party.
3. And there are the ideologues, though they seem to fall into a couple of camps: the religious nutjobs who want everyone to live under their version of X-treme fundamentalist patriarchal christianity; the architects of the disaster in the middle east; and the Norquistians and libertarians, who want to destroy government. If that isn't an unholy alliance, I don't know what the fuck is.
4. And there are the profiteers--the Enrons, and the AIGs, and the Halliburtons, and all the rest. Have you ever wondered why those people tend to vote Republican? Do the math.
But here's the thing. They like to prattle about "values" and small towns and plumbers, but which values, exactly, do they want to tout? The insular, racist values? (Well, yes, some of them like to incite those.) Oh, no, wait, they claim they want to tout the values of helping one's neighbor, and so on; those things that big-city folk don't do, because we're all evil unamerican evil people. And we probably have dark skin or are illegal immigrants. Which would explain the lines of people waiting to donate blood after 9-11. Which would explain the cops and firefighters, too. Oh, wait; they were city residents? Hmmm . . .
And they like to prattle about taxes, or, more recently, socialism. Fine; let's NOT bail out the banks. Let's fine the Wall Street executives--every last fucking one of them--and throw them in Riker's Island. Oh, wait, you think regulation might have helped? You think government oversight might have been a good thing? Not if you're a Republican or a libertarian.
And they like to go on about "real" Americans--like the governor who shleps her kids around and bills the government for it while wanting rape victims to pay for the collection of evidence and who likes to give speeches to secessionist groups of which her husband is a member, or the plumber who isn't licensed and can't do math but who thinks he's going to be making more than a quarter-million dollars a year, or the fundamentalists who want to come after you if you don't believe the way they believe, and they sure as hell don't want any women to have any kind of control over their own reproductive capacities.
Fuck that. Or, as Jon Stewart said, fuck all y'all, all the people making those accusations. I vote. I pay taxes. I work every day to help people who are worse off than I am (and worse off than any of the people doing the prattling), and the government pays my salary, and I am fine with having my taxes go to those ends. If that makes me unamerican, then I shudder to think what your definition of American is.
Wednesday, October 22, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
Sing it, sister!
Here's a link for Daily Show videos by day.
Don't take it personally, my urbanite friend. They really hate Massachusetts, town and country alike. We've learned to revel in it, to provoke them.
Great post!!
I grew up in a small town that was insular and mighty white, and while I live in a small town again now, it's neither of those things--being less than 5 miles from big East Coast City.
I think it's ridiculous when the Republicans try to isolate small town residents, and prey on their fears of the other, rather than trying to move both groups to appreciate each others' strengths.
Great rant, and I mean that in the nicest, most complimentary way. I especially like your breakdown/categorization of the Republicans.
I have thought quite a bit about that myself, and I think it's even simpler than you state. I think there are only two factions: call them the religious fundamentalists and the neocons. These names may not be as fully descriptive as I'd like, but I'm still working on them.
The fundamentalists have made a deal with the devil (the neocons) and here's the deal: They provide the attractive, electable, empty-headed candidate (Reagan, Bush 43, Palin) and in exchange the neocons provide the election machine (money, smears, computer hacking, vote suppression).
What's in it for each group? The fundamentalists get the power to impose anti-abortion laws, ant-gay laws, etc., and -- because the dimwitted candidate is fully malleable -- the neocons gain free rein to loot the treasury.
I really, really wish we could break the cycle of bitterness and recrimination. We may be about to see a huge turnaround in the makeup of our government, and I sincerely hope the new boss will not be the same as the old boss, to paraphrase The Who.
Post a Comment